[HPforGrownups] Re: Why Did McGonagall Wait For DD *All Day?*

Sherry Gomes sherriola at earthlink.net
Wed Aug 16 18:42:48 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 157029

Eyemlynn wrote:

> I kind of think that the only point to that [having McGonagall wait
all day for DD} was for her to say that the Dursleys were the worst sort of
muggles. Just a way of introducing them as bad people.



Sherry:

Actually, I've just been rereading SS/PS for another group's read through.
Minerva never said, in the books, that the Dursleys are the "worst sort of
Muggles".  That is movie contamination.  She said something about them being
as unlike the WW as it is possible to be.  I'm going by the audio book as
read by Jim dale, so it is the American edition.

Just clarifying.
Sherry





More information about the HPforGrownups archive