Copywrite Errors - Listed? (was:Voldemort killed personally?)
Mike
mcrudele78 at yahoo.com
Sun Aug 20 03:47:19 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 157172
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "carodave92" wrote:
> > Mike previously
> > For instance, did JKR ever say something about Lupin tying up
> > Pettigrew in the Shrieking Shack? I mean, he *walks* out and
> > after Lupin breaks free from the manacles, he grabs Lupin's
> > dropped wand. So neither his arms nor legs were tied up,
> > what was?
> >
> Carodave:
> I am going off memory here...so may not be 100% correct...but I
> believe that Lupin tied Pettigrew to himself on one side and to
> Ron on the other.
<snip>
Mike again:
No, it was like I said. Lupin told Harry to move aside so he could
tie up Pettigrew. *Then* Sirius conjures manacles to shackle Ron and
Lupin to either of Peter's arms. When Lupin transforms he breaks
free from the *manacles*. Peter dives for Lupin's dropped wand.
So the question still stands, what part of Pettigrew got tied up by
Lupin? Zanooda2 suggested to me that JKR forgot that she had Lupin
tie up Pettigrew. Hence, my question of whether JKR admitted
subsequent to the publishing of PoA that this was an unforced error.
(a little tennis lingo there)<g>
Mike
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive