[HPforGrownups] Re: Which Dumbledore ?

Jane Penhaligon penhaligon at gmail.com
Tue Aug 22 00:37:43 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 157262

> Abergoat writes:
> If I'm getting the right impression you think that it is 
> strange that if Aberforth truly resembles Dumbledore then 
> Harry should see the resemblance, right? I completely agree. 
> Sure Harry was distracted when Moody showed him a picture of 
> Aberforth, but if Aberforth looked like Dumbledore wouldn't 
> Harry register that? Dumbledore is Harry's new father figure 
> - and Harry certainly looked at the picture well enough to 
> see Peter and his parents. And I recall that Harry is still 
> looking to note that Moody isn't as scared as he is now.

Panhandle:
But what if Aberforth, say, doesn't have a beard? I think it might be quite
hard for Harry to spot Aberforth as a relative of Dumbledore if he didn't
wear a beard. Just a thought.

penhaligon at gmail.com





More information about the HPforGrownups archive