I'm new here so sorry if this isn't correct

[Michelle A. Tague]

No: HPFGUIDX 157318

Lynn wrote:
> I am curious how many times everyone has read the series. I 
> started reading in January for the first time and am 1/2 way 
> through my third time. <snip>

Sherry now:
>> <snip> I've read GOF four times I think, and COS, OOTP and HBP
twice. COS is my least favorite of the books. The death of Sirius 
and Dolores Umbridge bother me so much that I never can make it 
through OOTP, even though there are many things I really like about 
the book. I always stop when they get to the ministry for the 
battle. POA is my favorite of the three, and I expect I've read it 
six or seven times all the way through. <<


Michelle:

My order of favorites is from most to least:

HBP

PoA 

GOF

PS/SS

COS

OOTP

<http://geo.yahoo.com/serv?s=97359714&grpId=2176166&grpspId=1602544108&msgId
=157257&stime=1156202861&nc1=3848611&nc2=3848551&nc3=3848429>  
Friends of mine who are also big HP fans.... insist that OOTP is a 
great book... but it was too emotional for me.  And darnit I really 
wanted to punch that Umbridge in the face like 10000000 times in the book.
 
Is this more of a HPfGU Chatter list comment or is it ok on this regular list?
 
Michelle.