Crouch!Moody and the Goblet of Fire -- why so complicated?
spookedook
spookedook at yahoo.co.uk
Wed Aug 23 10:48:31 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 157337
James adds:
We have to remember that there were two goals, not one in LV's mind at
the time. It's obvious that he wanted/needed Harry. But you can't
overlook the second goal, to return without anyone having any
suspicions.
Eddie:
I can imagine this is true, but I'm not entirely persuaded. Does
Voldemort really care if anybody is suspicious or not? I can't recall
the canon now, but didn't Barty Crouch Jr. light the dark mark at the
Quidditch on Voldemort's orders? That doesn't seem in line with
trying to not raise suspicions about his return.
Tintonks butts in:
JKR says on her website when asked about why veritaserum is not used,
that it works more on the unsuspecting. I believe that this is the
same for all magic where the mind is a key defence (i.e the imperious
curse etc)
Also one of LV's greatest tools is fear. If you are unprepared for LV
turning up on your door, and know that nobody will suspect his hand in
you fate you are unlike;y to have any means of escape or protection.
Plus DD immediately begun taking measures against LV. I dont think we
have even touched on what these measures are but we undoubtedly will.
I dont think that BC Jr was supposed to put cast the dark mark in the
air. I'm pretty sure that he couldn't resist it because of his old
bitterness for all the DE's who roam free.
Tinktonks
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive