Splitting the Soul (was: Voldemort killed personally)

[Hagrid]

No: HPFGUIDX 157465

> Ken:
> I agree. My statement about the afterlife was only in regard to 
> how a horcrux would affect the eternal fate of its creator. I 
> should have been more clear about that. I don't think we have any 
> canon to support an opinion on the manner but since I support 
> those who are willing to speculate on the new canon that will 
> appear in book 7 I can hardly fault you for indulging in the 
> practice!
> 
> > Carol again:
> 
> > To return to the point, and to Ken's question, I think that a 
> > person who has created a Horcrux, like the victims of the 
> > Dementors, is denied access to the afterlife. The difference is 
> > that he's anchoring his own soul to the earth, permanently, he 
> > hopes, so that he can continue to live on earth forever (more of 
> > a cursed half-life, really, which is why most wizards, even 
> > murderers, don't try to create Horcruxes). 
> 
> Ken:
> 
> Of course we have no firm basis on which to say how
> Christian Rowling intends the Potterverse to be.
> 
> We all believe that Harry will succeed in sending LV's soul 
> piecemeal into the afterlife whether Harry survives the 
> experience or not. 
> 
> My question was about the eternal fate of the horcruxed once all 
> their separate soul bits are finally separated from the Earth and 
> reside in the afterlife. I suspect that it is different from those 
> who make the journey with whole souls or in the case of common 
> murderers with all the soul bits passing beyond at the same time. 
> Beyond that I suppose your speculation is as good as anyone's. I 
> would guess that book 7 will say something about the matter.

aussie: 
I doubt JKR will use Horry Potter as a platform to speak on 
Christian redemption, Politics, nor Homosexual Relationships.

They are too narrow and heated views with devisive appeal to too 
limited a target audience.

I am sure she would invite anyone wanting to use popular book series 
as a propaganda vehicle to start writing their own series. Just 
don't demand a different auther to adopt views important to you.

In canon, JKR has included ghosts, Inferius, the Mirror of Erised, 
and portraits with essence of the dead speaking to people. Some 
concepts may come from Greek mythology, but she invents a whole new 
World. A Wizarding World ... that those that call themselves witches 
and worlocks have little to do with. It is part of JKR's 
immagination and her reseach from other cultures' mythology.

One platform she may speak on is that of Amnesty International. Her 
emphasis on the descrimination from some purebloods is similar to 
the prejudice AI tries to overcome in some countries.

IMOO, God is not suprised by any man-made horcruxes or so 
called "Unforgiveable" acts. They are not something impossible from 
His original design. Whether a soul goes to the post-terrestrial 
life all at once or needing to be super-glued together does not 
alter His original order of things.

aussie