Which Dumbledore ?

[abergoat]

No: HPFGUIDX 157477

Tonks_op wrote:
> But seriously, I don't think that LV takes any prisoners, so to 
> speak. If he wanted informantion he would get it and then kill the 
> man. 

Abergoat writes:
Thanks for humoring me on this! I'm sure this will be the last post on
the subject but I just wanted to mention that Snape tells us that
Legilimens isn't as simple as 'mind reading' and there is a strong
indication that the person legilimensing sees only what the victim has
in their consciousness - hence Snape can hide things by blocking them.
Aberforth could have blocked the prophecy from Voldemort view - I
don't think that Voldemort managed to get the memory from Aberforth so
 perhaps he wasn't willing to kill Aberforth until he did.

Or perhaps Voldemort enjoyed the irony of turning his old
Transfiguration teacher's brother into a goat in such a way that
Dumbledore couldn't reverse it. This would be a daily reminder to
Dumbledore of Voldemort's power - Voldemort would like that.

Tonks_op wrote:
> By the way, I love your name. I almost hope you are right.

Thanks! I normally use 'Abbygoat' but that was taken on Yahoo.

Abergoat