What Came First: Task or Cabinet? - The Plan v1 & v2

[justcarol67]

No: HPFGUIDX 157651

> Magpie:
> You mean we might not get a different explanation besides that 
> whole "he wants Draco to die to punish Lucius" idea Narcissa brings 
> up in Spinner's End. It's not really presented as a mystery. 
>
Carol responds:
It isn't? Half the book is about Harry trying to find out what draco
is up to. Narcissa and Snape don't know, either, which is why the
Vanishing Cabinet plan doesn't come into "Spinner's End" or any of the
chapters involving Draco and Snape. Snape doesn't discuss what he
doesn't know, and Draco is keeping it secret.

And do you have an explanation for how Rosmerta was Imperio'd or how
the coins work or any of the other things that Draco mentioned on the
tower? I sure don't.

Carol