Harry, Draco and bathroom/ A couple of theories - Snape

[zanooda2]

No: HPFGUIDX 162435

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "dumbledore11214" 
<dumbledore11214 at ...> wrote:
 
> > Jenni from Alabama (wishing the voice would just shut up!)
 
> > zanooda:
 
> > Haha, I wish I had a voice in my head telling me that Snape is 
> > ESE! In this case, if it turns out to be true, I could at least 
> > say that I had my doubts :-). 


> Alla:
 
> That is a good analogy. I believe that Snape only cares for himself 
> and would not hesitate to do an evil deed if it will help him or 
> that he is acting under Life debt premise, but I always have this 
> voice, hehe - as I mentioned , it will help me to not be too 
> dissapointed if Snape is DD!M :)


zanooda:

Yeah, it's wise to have doubts and voices in our heads, they will 
save us from huge disappointments when the last book is out. I have 
many doubts myself, for example about Harry being a Horcrux, or about 
the whole Snape/Lily thing. I have my preferences, but I'm ready to 
accept whatever JKR will throw at us.
 
It's different with Snape though. I would be really, really 
disappointed if Snape turned out to be ESE. OFH!Snape would be OK, I 
guess, but ESE!Snape? It would be just not interesting enough for me. 
Snape would become boring and insignificant, and that would be a 
shame, because I think he is brilliantly written and has so much 
potential as a character (which doesn't make him a more pleasant 
person, of course).
 
We have a whole long (hopefully) book ahead of us, and what would ESE!
Snape do there, without a mystery, without a twist? Bo-ring! We would 
hardly see him anymore, I guess (yeah, I know, I know, you'll be only 
too happy not to see him anymore, Alla :-)). Or, maybe we would see 
him, if LV puts him in charge of "Harry-hunting", but, again, even 
this would be not as exciting as Snape turning out to be DDM at the 
end.

zanooda, who is not quite sure if this post is off-topic or not, and 
who apologizes if it is.