Professor Snape- Master of This School!

dumbledore11214 dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Wed Dec 6 20:03:38 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 162460

Dantzel:

> When listening to Prisoner of Azkaban, I just picked up how 
incredibly 
> arrogant Snape is in one particular scene. After Harry's head is 
seen 
> by Draco and he gets pulled into Snape's office for questioning, 
Snape 
> finds the Maurader's Map and tries to find out what it is. He 
> says, "Professor Severus Snape, master of this school, commands you 
to 
> yield the information you conceal!"
> 
> Does this strike anyone else as rather arrogant and perhaps power 
> hungry? We see throughout the books his desire to have more power 
over 
> others (especially the Spinner's End chapter for a more recent 
> example). Does this have any other implications for the future? 
Perhaps 
> this is evidence for OFH!Snape or even ESE!Snape?
>
<SNIP>

Alla:

HAHA. I do not know about the implications for the future, although I 
would dearly love it to be true of course :)

But sure I agree that Snape calling himself Potions Master shows his 
arrogance.

I remember the arguments made that Snape as Potion Master shows his 
extra education or something, basically that it is somehow special. 

There is a quote in HBP or OOP, which I cannot check now (posting 
from work), where narrator ( I think) casually says that tiny Charms 
Master comes through or something.

Do we **ever** hear Flitwick calling himself that? I think it was JKR 
poking fun at Snape again.

JMO,

Alla





More information about the HPforGrownups archive