OFH, Life-debt and Snape/Lily-no-way

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 162495

> > Carol:
> > Indeed we may and probably will. After all, JKR has promised us 
more
> > information on the Prank--primarily James's motives, I think. 
Sirius
> > won't look very good, either, I suspect. 
> 
> Neri:
> I suspect differently. James too looked very bad after OotP, and 
then 
> JKR turned the table in HBP. She can do it again with the Prank if 
it 
> fits with her goals. Easily.


Alla:

LOLOL. Sirius **already** does not look good at all with the 
information we have about Prank, me thinks. If any reevaluation is to 
follow, he has nowhere to go but up IMO.

But I do not think that Sirius would look much better, I mean I do 
not think we will get any support to the claim of Sirius wanting to 
**kill** Snape, but even without that, there are plenty bad words to 
describe what he did.

Snape on the other hand, oh yes I do predict that we will learn that 
he was so very far from blameless of what happened that night.

Neri, just think of how easy that would be to do - all that needed is 
to say that Snape did not waste time reading that werewolf essay in 
pensieve scene and figured out way before he went to Shack who Remus 
was and that he went to Shack to prove how good of Dark art experts 
he was to kill that dark creature, with the curse of his own 
invention, no less.

Ummmm, yeah, that I can see happening.



> Neri:
> Yes, but JKR has been very silent about those "other things" for 
the 
> whole series. A silence that I personally finds ominous, but it 
> certainly helped the DDM!Snapers in ignoring these deeds. It might 
> turn out less easy to ignore them when we know what they were.   


Alla:

Oh, Neri. No matter how many murders we will learn that Snape 
committed, no matter how many innocent lives he destroyed, it had all 
been for the noble cause.
 
> Neri:
> Well, if it's any consolation, it looks like your "I was wrong" 
post 
> will be lost among hundreds of other such posts from all the rest 
of 
> the DDM!Snapers, while my "I was wrong" post isn't going to enjoy 
> that advantage <g>.
> 

Alla:

LOL. I know I would be dissapointed if Snape would be DD!M, but why 
would I be upset to write my I was wrong letter?

This is all for fun anyways. I promise to write mine the moment after 
we will reopen for business after book 7 is out if needed :)