Draco's alleged dark mark
mandrina_q
aratchford at gmail.com
Thu Dec 7 18:49:12 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 162506
Hello all,
I have been dealing with this itchy theory- farm in the back of my
head and I would like your opinions on this. I have searched the old
messages for a few hours looking for theories on this and have not
found them. if they're there, I'd appreciate the link... otherwise
please chime in.
In HBP Ch. 24, we all know how badly Draco is injured. We also know
that Snape (perhaps spying on Narcissa's behest) is there- like magic-
to heal him. However, we also know that Draco gets taken to the
hospital wing to be further cared for by Madam Pomfrey (I take this
to be like post-op care... he's all sewn up, but it was still trauma
to his body and then there's the 'might scar' scenario).
If Draco has the dark mark on his left arm as Harry suspects...
would Madam Pomfrey not have seen it when ministering to his wounds?
He would have had to have had his shirt and undershirt removed for
her to properly examine all of the places where Harry slashed him
open. That would certainly have exposed his left arm. And even if
Snape had healed the wounds enough that she didn't need to remove his
shirts, would she not insist on changing his bloody clothing?
would Snape have though of that and found a way to mask the dark mark
before taking Draco to Madam Pomfrey?
Or does Draco not have the mark yet? I wonder if Voldemort's order
is like other magical orders of lore, and if Draco has not yet been
through the proper initiation to earn the Dark Mark. This is a big
bone of contention in my house at the moment.
Please offer up your own theories. :)
Thanks
-MQ
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive