[HPforGrownups] Re:Wrong-headed compassion (was Re: Harry Draco and bathroom)

[Jordan Abel]

No: HPFGUIDX 162822

On 12/13/06, pippin_999 <foxmoth at qnet.com> wrote:
> There lies the answer also to those who think that if Harry had only
> let Pettigrew be slain, Trelawney's second prophecy would not have
> come true and Voldemort would never have returned. I'm afraid it
> would only have meant that a  different servant of Voldemort would
> set out to join him that night.

The prophecy in question actually applies equally to Crouch Jr. In
fact, it applies better, as Pettigrew was _in hiding_, not "chained".
The adaptation that shall not be named butchered the prophecy to make
it "more clear" for teh kiddies and eliminate this alternate
interpretation.

-- 
Random832