The Cabinet Plan...again (was:Re: The UV (was ESE, DDM, OFH, or Grey?)

eviljunglechicken eviljunglechicken at yahoo.com
Fri Dec 15 23:57:27 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 162829

-
> Alla:
>
> There is stupid IMO and there is stupid. It is completely
> unbelievable to me that Draco would not guess that Greyback would
> come not because he knows the name, but precisely because Draco
> threatens Borgin with the name - the leap to make from there is  not
> big for me.
>

I'll see this stupid and raise you a moron.  It seems beyond reason
that Harry would not suspect an unknown spell and one conveniently
labelled "for enemies" could be a potentially lethal one.

Is he not an orphan due to the flick of a wand and an utterance of
words?  Has he not seen a murder with the same before his very eyes?

I would certainly be wary.

But according to what we get in the book, we should indeed believe
that he is just a moron.

eviljunglechicken





More information about the HPforGrownups archive