Snape getting off scott free/ Ending for Snape

antonia31h antonia31h at yahoo.com
Tue Dec 19 09:24:49 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 162920

--
> Alla:
>
> One learns something new every day about fellow list members indeed.
> I would have never, ever nailed you as sentimental type :)  I mean of
> course we show here only small parts of who we are in our posts, but
> I would have never assumed that you may have any sort of emotional
> attachment to the characters. Now, do not get me wrong, while I hope
> Snape suffers horribly, I totally understand and accept the idea of
> hoping your favorite character will survive and have some sort of
> happiness etc. I mean, I never hide that the only thing that would
> stop me from rereading the books would be Harry's death, so I get why
> one would want Snape to live if one feels for him, empathises with
> him, etc.
>
> I totally know several Snape fans, whom I would absolutely said feel
> that way, but not you. I find it very interesting. Thank you, Dung :)


Why does Severus have to suffer horribly? Why do I get the feeling
that people hate him even more than they hate Voldemort or any other
evil character? Is it because we are not sure to whom he is loyal?
I really don't consider his actions being so despicable in the books
so that everyone should hate him. Yes, he tends to treat his students
badly, especially Harry & comp but we must also take in account that
Harry seems to hate him instinctively no matter what Severus does.
I don't know what you think about this but I feel that Harry is being
unjust to Severus from the very beginning. I mean if a person is not
that nice to us, do we have to hate him? Maybe this is just his style
his personality, his way of handling things.
antonia





More information about the HPforGrownups archive