[HPforGrownups] Re: Snape and Umbridge and abuse again/ Ending for Snape

[Scarah]

No: HPFGUIDX 162983

Cassie:
I would find it odd if Voldemort had never been romantically loved,
even if he had never returned the affection.  Scenes from his past
always suggest he was very handsome and talented.  I'd imagine many
girls would at LEAST have a crush on him.

Sarah:
Miss Hepzibah certainly seems quite taken in.  I wouldn't be surprised
if other women weren't either, but I don't think this sort of thing
qualifies as real "love" in JK's mind.  No one has ever loved him,
therefore Bellatrix doesn't.  So techicalities exist like fawning
adoration, devotion, etc. not being the same as love.

When I first read the Occlumency lessons, I thought Snape's behavior
and treatment of Harry was surprisingly nice and forthcoming compared
to his usual standard.  He started in on a couple of thoughts I would
have really liked to hear him finish, but of course Harry interrupted
him.

Sarah