Broken potionvial WAS: Re: Bad Writing? (was: JKR and the boys)

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 162993

> Potion-"The Wall"-cat:
<SNIP>
> Usually he's 
> using his power, but for a teacher to drop the vial seems weak. I 
> can't see Snape making himself look weak in front of the class. 
> However he often supports Slytherin misbehavior against 
Gryffindors 
> cough"I see no difference"cough and this seems more in that vein.
> 
> You realise, Snape doesn't come out any better if Draco is the one 
> who broke it.

Alla:

Well, I agree with Wynnleaf whom I snipped completely that this is 
just supposed to be what it is IMO.

But when Potioncat enters the discussion of that episode, Alla 
usually abandons her stance of Snape was the one and only who broke 
the vial, since Snape never stops from anything to execute revenge 
on Harry and agrees with Potioncat that somebody else could have 
done that indeed.

But not Draco, surely he won't be that bold in front of whole class?

That was Snape twins helping out and unde invisibility cloak too.


Disclaimer:

Please refer to Potioncat for all further questions as to Snape 
twins backstory. She is the one responsible for their existance 
after all ;)

Alla, running away and fast.