Harry Potter en Het Fatale Heiligdom
Maria Vaerewyck
maria8162001 at yahoo.com
Thu Dec 28 15:16:57 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 163227
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "justcarol67" <justcarol67 at ...>
wrote:
> Carol responds:
> Hi, Maria. Thanks for that information, which I think is more
helpful
> than rough translations found in newspaper articles. It must be
> sanctioned by JKR herself to appear on her site (though I hope that
> speakers of other languages will confirm it for us). I'll assume for
> the moment that you're right--it's a place (which was my original
> impression, in any case).
maria8162001
Hi Carol, thanks also for your theory, it's very good and it goes
with one of my guesses that the founders will have something to do in
book 7 only in my theory It's more with their spirit or ghosts but
before I go further here's the HP dutch site in case anybody wants to
read it. Yes, I think too that JKR had approved it or they would not
put it on their site or they could have just follow the literal
translation also.
> Of course, the Veil or the locked room could be correct, though
> strictly speaking, I don't think they would be "hallowed" or "holy."
> So, since another title registered with the patent office was "HP
and
> the Hogwarts Hallows," I'm going with the burial place of the
Founders
> somewhere on the Hogwarts grounds, maybe a catacomblike place
beneath
> the dungeons, similar to the Chamber of Secrets but not requiring
> Parseltongue to enter.(?)
maria8162001:
Your theory of a catacomb of the founders fits well with the other
translation of the heiligdom which means "shrine", as shrine can also
be defined as a building or sturcture that house the relic or bones
of a revered or holy person. The way I read the HP books aren't the 4
founders revered by the WW especially those who goes to Hogwarts,
either studying or teaching or working? That's very good as I never
read yet on any posts that anybody here, aside from you suggested the
catacombs of the founders, as most of us are going for the very
obvious places. Cheers.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive