Broken potionvial WAS: Re: Bad Writing? (was: JKR and the boys)

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 163239

> Jen: <SNIP> Harry after he drank Felix would be an example of 
Harry acting cocky 
> in my book. <SNIP>

Alla:

Me too :)


> Jen: Counter to what I said above, *if* Snape was ignoring Harry 
> because he's embarassed or unsure what Harry would do and the 
broken 
> vial was Harry's fault, why can't he keep his big mouth shut for 
once 
> and not act so snide?  Why does the guy have to talk so much?  I'm 
> with Alla on this one.  Seriously, is it because we can't hear his 
> thoughts that we have to hear so much dialogue from him and much 
of 
> it repetitive?  


Alla:

Hehe.
As Ceridwen already knows from me, hehe, I am really really not sure 
that Snape ignoring Harry because he was embarassed, exposed ( 
sinister me still keeps in mind the possibility that he left 
pensieve on purpose and was biting his time, but this is for another 
thread), means that he would have avoided the personal interaction.

I think that Snape avoiding Harry could have also meant Snape biting 
his time and planning his petty revenge - destroying Harry's potion 
on purpose can also mean that Snape planned it and executed it to 
the perfection IMO.