Is Bella a killer? WAS:,Re: Could Deathly Hallows

[pippin_999]

No: HPFGUIDX 163274


Jeremiah:
> 
> (I think it was ok for them to kill Harry at the minstry only if it wouldn't
> harm the prophesy... I'll have to look that up...) but she could have killed
> Sirius and I can't figure out why except that she's not a killer... meaning
> someone who kills for fun or just because they can.
> 
> The fox.. that was a reaction to fear. Almost like self defense.
> 
> So, I see has as all talk... or, more precisely: Lots of talk and does back
> up her felloow DE's but not a murderer just a sadist who likes to hear
> sreams from torture... She's still a sicko...

Pippin:
May I interest you in the theory that she didn't kill Sirius at all? Lupin
was between Harry and the platform. If Sirius was looking surprised
as he died, it could be because the attack came from someone he
didn't expect. Canon does not tell us where the second jet of light
came from. Harry assumes it was Bella's but she never claims credit
for killing Black. 

Sirius said something very interesting before he died. He told Harry to
take the prophecy and run. But Dumbledore said that if he had told
Harry everything, Harry would have known there was no need to go
to the ministry. What did Sirius know, and why did he think the prophecy
needed to be defended? And did someone kill him to keep him from
revealing the source of his knowledge?

Pippin