Which Halloween? (was Re: My thoughts on the title)

[Steve]

No: HPFGUIDX 163287

--- "Jeremiah LaFleur" <hpfreakazoid at ...> wrote:

> 
> Jeremiah:
> 
> .... there has been chatter about "All Hallows" meaning
> the Final Battle will take place on Halloween and that
> Pagan tradition says that All Haollows (Samhain) is the
> night whn there "veil" between the worlds of the living
> and dead are the thinnest: meaning the battle will be 
> at the Ministry for Magic at the veil where Sirius was
> killed. ...
> 

bboyminn:

Sorry, I'm off on a tangent here. The problem I have with
Halloween being the time of the Final Battle between 
Harry and Voldemort is that Halloween come to early in 
the story. It is either going to be a very short book,
or the only possible alternative is that it is TWO
Halloweens from now. It is the Halloween one full year
after Harry's seventh year at Hogwarts. 

Still doesn't sound that clear when I try to explain it.
So, it is either going to be Halloweed two months from 
the beginning of the current school year, or it is going
to be 14 months after the beginning of the current 
school year. Will the books break the mold and span a
time of more than one year? 

See what I'm getting at here?

Steve/bboyminn