An Introduction and some thoughts about HPADH

[Kevin Contini]

No: HPFGUIDX 163297

I am also new to the group, but not new to HP. My name is Kevin and I look forward to some wonderful HP debates/discussions.

Shannon:

"My take on Snape is that he is evil, the question in my mind remains: How evil is he? Snape is redeemable, I believe, but only at great cost to himself. He can save Harry, but first I think Harry has to save him."



You said that you believe that Snape is redeemable for what he did in HBP.  After reading the Ultimate Unofficial Guide to the Mysteries of Harry Potter(Analysis of Books 1-4), I believe that Snape did what he did as part of the task given to him by Dumbledore near the end of GOF. The Guide stated that Dumbledore told this to Snape rather cryptically so I am further analyzing what JK said through Albus and what the authors of the Guide have implied.  Anything is possible.

Kevin