Lupin and Wolfsbane potion
Amber
duckyslilangel_2 at yahoo.com
Fri Feb 3 04:30:40 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 147527
Carol:
> (He also states that he was never good at Potions; Snape, we
> know, is a genius at making them.) <snip>
Allie:
> <snip> Okay, even if it's very complicated and requires a lot
> of hard to find ingredients, what else does Lupin have to do?
> For crying out loud, Hermione learned how to make Polyjuice
> Potion at 12 years old, and that's also described as immensely
> complicated! <snip>
Amber:
Yes, Hermione did learn how to make the polyjuice postion at 12,
but it has been stated many times that she is a very gifted
student. This is not something that most 12 yr olds would be able
to do. Slughorn even said that it was not expected of them to do
until Newt level because of its difficulty. Also, Lupin has said,
he is not good at potions, others have said this as well. While I
do acknowledge that he does have a lot of free time to attempt it,
the full moon does come once a month. This would make it very hard
to do if it takes awhile to make. As JKR hasn't said exactly what
must be done to make this, we have no way of knowing if there are
certain steps to take at different times. Just thought I would put
my two cents into the mix!
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive