Lack of Memorial for Sirius (was Re: JKR's dealing with emotions)

[mmmwintersteiger]

No: HPFGUIDX 147570

> lucianam 

>I might as well put up a great big HE IS ALIVE!! neon sign accross 
>my front door(I mean Sirius)... So she's not cruel or insensitive, 
>just clever and her not giving much thought to Sirius in HBP will 
>make sense in Book 7.



michelle says:

I agree, SIRIUS IS ALIVE.  I'm not sure how he comes back but he did 
not die in the MoM.  This has been something that I have been most 
adamant about.  However the lack of memorial or mention still bothers 
me.  It seems to me that by not having some kind of service JKR has 
made it too obvious that he is alive.  She hasn't given any finality 
on Sirius-unlike DD who had a huge memorial service.

michelle