Lack of Memorial for Sirius -He's Alive (repost)

[Steve]

No: HPFGUIDX 147604

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "mmmwintersteiger"
<mmmwintersteiger at ...> wrote:
>
> > lucianam 
> 
> >I might as well put up a great big HE IS ALIVE!! neon sign 
> >accross >my front door(I mean Sirius)... So she's not cruel
> >or insensitive, just clever and her not giving much thought
> >to Sirius in HBP will make sense in Book 7.
> 
> 
> 
> michelle says:
> 
> I agree, SIRIUS IS ALIVE.  I'm not sure how he comes back but he
> did not die in the MoM.  This has been something that I have been 
> most adamant about.  However the lack of memorial or mention 
> still bothers me. It seems to me that by not having some kind of 
> service JKR has made it too obvious that he is alive.  She hasn't 
> given any finality on Sirius-unlike DD who had a huge memorial 
> service.
> 
> michelle
>

bboyminn:

I hope you will all forgive me for taking this opportunity to repost
one of my favorite theories. Because it has been touched on before in
this group and in another, I will try to keep it brief.

The Theory -

Can't say that it's all true, but it is an interesting theory.

Others, in discussing this, have speculated that we will discover,
much to Harry's own surprise, that he has the power of possession. In
the last battle in front of the Veiled Arch, Voldemort will possess
Harry for what ever reason, but Harry will turn the tables and possess
Voldemort, and take him and all the Horcruxes through the Veil, ending
Voldemort once and for all.

Extending this further, we can say that Sirius went through the Veil
under 'special circumstances'. He went in fully alive with both body
and spirit completely in tact. I extended my original 'Veil Theory'
(#142371) to include the possibility of Harry Possessing Voldemort and
taking him through. Because Voldemort and Harry travel through the
Veil as a single living being, due to /special circumstances/,
Voldemort doesn't die until Harry leaves Voldemort's body. The problem
is, when Harry leaves Voldemort's body, Harry also dies.

Now the question is, how does Harry get out without dying? Simple,
Sirius touches Voldemort's body (hand on shoulder), and Harry moves
his possession from Voldemort through the contact point into Sirius.
By doing so, Voldemort dies but Harry has never been alone in the
realm beyond the Veil; he is still protected from death by sharing a
body with another. Now, Harry walks Sirius body out from behind the
Veil, and then, your choice, when Harry leaves Sirius's body, Sirius
either lives or dies, but for sure Harry lives.

Now Harry REALLY IS "The Boy Who Lived". He went to the Land of the
Dead and returned. How cool is that?

Additional bonus: he gets to spend some time with his parents.

Additional additional bonus: maybe Sirius gets to live too.

Yes, I know... pure speculation, but still it's an intriguing thought.

Just passing it along.

Steve/bboyminn