CHAPDISC: HBP9, The Half-Blood Prince

[zgirnius]

No: HPFGUIDX 147684

 
> AyanEva: 
>  Snape is too meticulous and orderly, I cannot 
> > believe that he would not know what was and was not left in his 
> > classroom and the content of each thing that was there. Why the 
> heck 
> > would that sort of book that would allow students to "cheat" be 
> left 
> > lying around??
> 
> Potioncat:

> Also, I don't think of it as a book that allows students to cheat, 
> but a book that a student make improvements in. 

zgirnius:
I also do not think this book would have allowed a student to 'cheat' 
in Snape's Potions classes. It is a peculiarity of his that he wrote 
his potions instructions on the board. I suspect this is because he 
wrote his own instructions on the board-so having Snape's old notes 
would not have given any student an advantage over the others.