Dumbledore's hand and UV
mmmwintersteiger
mmmwintersteiger at yahoo.com
Wed Feb 8 20:51:27 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 147811
> >> Cat:
> > I can't say whether or not DD would make an unbreakable vow, but
> > as for it being dark magic, how would the twins know about it at
> > the age of 6, <snip> How would the twins know about the linked
> > hands and everything? And where would they have learned the
> > spell? I highly doubt that the Weasleys have books on the Dark
> > Arts in their house for them to learn from.
>
> Allie:
> Excellent, excellent point! Unless the twins had WITNESSED an
> unbreakable vow being made or heard a detailed discussion of how
> it's done. <snip>
You do have to take into account that Arthur works for the MoM. I'm
sure he has had many "adult" conversations with friends that the
twins could have overheard. With that in mind, I am also convinced
that most wizards have at least some knowledge of the dark arts but
make a conscious decision not to use them.
michelle
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive