James and Lily defying Voldemort

[h2so3f]

No: HPFGUIDX 147876

Dave wrote: <edited >
"CH3ed wrote:
h> At the end of OotP Harry had escaped 
h> LV alive 4 times against LV's will;
h> 1. in PS/SS from the dungeon
h> 2. in CoS from the Chamber of Secrets (with Tom Riddle)
h> 3. in GoF from the graveyard scene
h> 4. in OotP from the fight at the MoM

I'm with you on 1, 3, & 4, but I've never been sure if the fourth
occasion refers to the CoS or Godric's Hollow."


CH3ed:
Yeah. I wondered about that too, but I ended up scoring GH for Lily 
instead of for Harry, since she was the one that did the actual 
facing with LV. Harry in that scene wasn't doing anything but 
getting hit by the AV curse, which then rebounded off him because of 
Lily's sacrifice. On the other hand both Lily and James died in the 
scene.... but Lily's death gave the protection that defied and 
destroyed LV... so I guess Lily's final tally is 1 more than James? 

CH3ed :O)