[HPforGrownups] Re: My 7 book 7 predictions- to Alla

[Bee Chase]

No: HPFGUIDX 147937



dumbledore11214 <dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com> wrote:    > After JKR giving Remus love interest, I feel much more confident 
> that he will live. Oh, and of course he was not and never will be 
> ESE. :-0
> 
> Luckdragon: No arguments on Lupin's goodness; but don't you find 
it strange that this relationship was just thrown into the mix 
without prior 
> clues. How would this work? Good a metamorphagus and Auror as 
Tonks may be even Moody wasn't able to remain entirely in one piece 
and fell victim to Crouch Jr. It would just be too dangerous to marry 
a Werewolf (Lupin knows it).

Alla:

Well, what can I say ? The relationship did jump on me pretty much 
out of nowhere, but I think that this is where the argument that 
Harry does not see everything can work well to explain "out of 
nowhere part". I don't see any more than usual difficulties because 
Tonks is an auror and Remus is werewolf. He is pretty much not 
dangerous when he drinks a potion and she has a dangerous job, but 
many people have dangerous jobs and many people have chronic 
illnesses. Relationships are difficult in general, I don't see theirs 
necessarily as more difficult than many others. IMO of course.

Personally, I would much more preferred Remus to be in relationship 
with Sirius, but for some reason I remember well a phrase at one of 
the discussions table at Witching Hour symposium. "JKR gave Remus a 
love interest in order for him to have a reason to stay alive". I 
happen to agree with it. I mean one would hope that Harry was at 
least part of such reason too. We shall see.
   
  LD again: Lupin and Sirius as a couple would have been a fun twist IMO. Who will make Lupin's "complex" potion now that Snape is MIA?
  Also what if LV finds a way to use Tonks to get to Lupin. That is the whole reason Harry set his relationship with Ginny aside for the time being. I think any new open relationship right now could be detrimental to one of the parties, particularly when one has a hairy little problem and his aid is no longer available.


> Alla:
> If Harry dies, he will be reunited with his loved ones behind the 
> Veil, if he does not, he will NOT be Frodo Potter. He will get a 
> chance to live a reasonably normal happy life. Maybe "twelve kids" 
> prediction will come true.
> 
> Luckdragon: Goodness, I hope not the 12 kids part.
> 

Alla:

Heeee. Why not? You don't want Harry to stay kids or you just want 
him to have that many? :-)
   
  LD again: I'm an Early Childhood Educator. The thought of 12 kids 24/7 is very daunting. I would really like to see Harry be able to travel and enjoy the world after years living in a cupboard under the stairs and a dorm with 4 other boys. Hard to do with 12 kids.


> Alla:
> Oh, of course the AK Snape performed was very real, not fake.
> 
>Luckdragon: That I won't believe till the last page of book 7 ends.
> 

Alla:

Snort. What if at some point in time JKR will write on her website in 
Rumors section or FAQ section something to the effect.

"Dumbledore is dead and AK killed him". Would you believe it then?
   
   
  LD again: Frankly I don't take anything on her site at face value just yet. I'm sure something she has told us will be a trick; either Sirius or DD or Regulus is really alive or there are more horcruxes than we know, or Neville is really "The one". I don't know if I'm an Optimist or a Pessimist, but I keep expecting a surprise.

Alla: 
Couple more predictions from me, I think I read everybody else's, but 
I may have missed something, so forgive me if I by accident repeat 
somebody else's prediction:

Harry will return to Hogwarts, but will be leaving it often to go 
hunting just as Dumbledore did.
   
  Luckdragon: Totally thinking the same thing here. Hogwarts will be home base, the Library and teachers will be Harry's resources, Students, ghosts, portraits and Elves will aid Harry as well. There may even be a horcrux lurking on the grounds.
  
Alla:
One of the possible endings for dear Voldemort I can think of ( that 
was not said in this thread, but I may have seen it earlier or 
discussed it with somebody) would be Voldemort turning into a baby 
at the end and Harry taking a pity on him and not killing him for 
that reason ( have no clue who would take care of this "baby" after 
all though – maybe St.Mungo?). It is not my favorite one by all 
means, but I keep thinking about "baby face" DE at the MoM battle and 
Hermione's "we cannot hurt a baby" ( paraphrase, but I think 
essentially correct one) and I can see this kind of end.
   
  Luckdragon: Interesting experiment. Nurture vs. nature. Put baby Tom in a loving home and see if things turn out differently. Would the magic world dare chance it.



__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam?  Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around 
http://mail.yahoo.com 

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]