DD and Snape's Culpability

[latha279]

No: HPFGUIDX 148064

> brady:
> > I also have a feeling that Snape knows the complete prophecy. 
> > He only told LV what DD told him to tell. 
> 
> houyhnhnm:
> I have been coming around to this belief.  I can't figure out any 
> other explanation for the fact that Trelawney knew Snape was 
> present.  He must have still been present when she came out of her 
> trance, therefore he must have heard the entire prophecy.  (or 
> course that also means DD wasn't telling Harry the truth in the 
> broom shed--either that or Snape really was the spider on his hat)

brady:

:) Spider on the hat! Good one that. 

Yes, indeed, I came to that conclusion only because Trelawney knew 
Snape was there. She said he interrupted her interview. But there is 
no way she could have known of anything at that time. She goes into a 
trance and she loses consciousness of the outer world. And when she 
comes around, doesn't remember about the trance part of it. So, DD 
knew something about Snape that he used to blackmail him or something 
that we have not yet been told about that stopped Snape from giving 
the entire prophecy to LV. 

Anyways, it is definitely going to be such a long painful wait till 
we get our answers. I love thrillers, but hate suspenses. 

Brady.