What's in Snape'sname?
potioncat
willsonkmom at msn.com
Tue Feb 14 12:03:00 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 148138
Deborah wrote:
> I've been skipping a lot of Snape postings lately. Not that I don't
> enjoy him greatly as a character ... but there's been too much chewing
> over too many old bones to hold my interest. Sorry, but there it is.
>Why, of all things, call the lad Snivellus?
Potioncat:
There's nothing new under the sun, this is another "old bone." If you
want to see some real bone cracking conversation, you should look
waaaay back to some snivelling discussions between Valky, Carol and
myself, (and a few others). It was dictionaries at 10 paces!
The two main views have already shown up in replies to your question,
but that doesn't stop me from explaining them:
One was that Severus, in violation of the schoolyard rule, ran crying
to teachers with complaints about the Marauders. This would be
the "snivelling coward" view. We do have Sirius's statement that Snape
was always trying to get them in trouble so he may have tattled quite a
bit.
The other view is that at some time for some unknown reason, the
Marauders either made him cry or found him crying and stuck him with
the name Snivelus. JKR has used the word snivelling in the sense of
crying in SS/PS. Dudley is described as snivelling in the back seat
when Vernon rushed everyone into the the car and drove like a maniac.
So, until we find out for sure, if we ever do, you can take your pick.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive