I think I know what one of the horcruxes is.
susanbones2003
rkdas at charter.net
Thu Feb 16 20:31:26 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 148252
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, catherine higgins
<saberbunny at ...> wrote:
>
> Constance Vigilance wrote:
> If Voldy was going to make his 6th and final horcrux with the
> killing of Harry, and that failed, then there should be two Voldy
> bits floating around, no? The bit that didn't become the horcrux
and
> the one he intended to keep in his body. I'm thinking that now
that
> he is corporeal again, he could have made horcruxes to replace the
> lost ones, if he knows they are lost. But in his first pass, I'm
> thinking there must have been one less horcrux than Dumbledore
> thinks. Does anyone agree?
>
> Catherine wrote:
> But there's one bit of crucial infomation we're missing. When
> exactly do you cast the Horcrux-creating spell? I got the impre-
> ssion from Slughorn's memory that it had to be done *after* the
> killing curse (I could have misinterperated it though). And DD
> seems to think that a Horcrux could not have been created at that
> time since Voldie got hit by the rebounded curse before finalising
> the Horcrux-creating spell. I think HRH (and we) will have to find
> out more about how to make a Horcrux (Horcruxes for Dummies?)
> before figuring out if one was made at Godric's Hollow.
> Catherine
>
Hi there,
This point is an aside but it does have something to do with your
point. Dumbledore theorizes that LV made Nagini a horcrux with the
death of an old muggle man (Frank Bryce) and this was when he only
had the tiny scaly baby body. That to me seems very amazing. I was
under the impression he was pretty much helpless at that point. I
certainly understand he couldn't have created a horcrux after the AK
rebounded onto him and left him less than the meanest ghost, but I
was amazed at the thought that the scaly baby could do such a thing.
Am I missing another muggle that DD could have been refering to? I
have wracked my brain and the text, and don't come up with any other
muggle murder. If this is the murder, it definitely seems that Peter
would have had to have helped. Makes you wish Harry's dream could
have gone on another few minutes.
Jen D. floating another one of those little bits roaming around in
her brain...
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive