My 7 book 7 predictions

lagattalucianese katmac at katmac.cncdsl.com
Fri Feb 17 02:04:17 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 148281

> 
...
> 
> > > Luckdragon:
> > > 3) Snape will be  redeemed.
> 
...
> 
> Exodusts:
> 3) He will be simultaneously mortally  wounded/redeemed in a vital 
> strike against Voldemort, saving Harry. Just  time for a 
> reconciliatory chat with his last breath.
>  
> Julie:
> That's what I expect also. Nothing else to add ;-)
> 
I still like the idea of Snape being saved at the last minute by 
Neville. It would be the ultimate pay-back--Snape having to live with 
the thought that he owes a life debt to Neville Longbottom.
> 
> > >  Luckdragon:
> > > 4) Someone utterly shocking will be revealed as  ESE!
> 
...> 
> Exodusts:
> 4) No. Snape being revealed as ESG! is the "big  twist" of book 7.
>  
> Julie:
> LOL, but I don't think so. Snape will remain ESC!, or  ever-so-
conflicted,
> too steeped in bitterness to slough off his nastier traits, but  
compelled
> by his loyalty to Dumbledore and his own conscience (yes, I do think
> he has one) to do the right thing (when it comes to the bigger  
picture
> anyway). He will also be revealed as DDM!, which will  be an eye-
opener
> for Harry. Hmm, Snape and Harry, two sides of the DDM coin  ;-)
> 
La Gatta Lucianese:

I also like the idea of him turning out to be not only DDM but 
Harry's cousin on the distaff side. Interesting excuse for 
rapprochement, and Harry would learn the reasons (besides Snape's 
hatred of James) for all the sniping, detentions, and other meanness 
during Harry's stay at Hogwarts. Also what really happened that night 
on the Astronomy Tower.
> 
> > > Luckdragon:
> > > 5) LV will succumb to the  Dementor's Kiss after Harry 
destroy's 
> > > the 
> > >  Horcruxes.
> 
...
>  
> Julie:
> I like the idea of the Dementor's sucking the soul part out of  
Harry's
> scar! In fact, maybe that's why they're so attracted to Harry. And 
if
> LV is soul-sucked by the Dementors, that's not really dying, but 
> living on as a soulless shell. (Though it still seems like dying 
to  me,
> unless it's analogous to being fully paralyzed with your mind 
intact,
> since how else would one know how dreadful their soul-sucked 
> existence is?)
> 
La Gatta Lucianese:

See my last post. I think dying is too good for Voldemort. I don't 
think it's Harry's place to kill him, any more than it was Frodo's to 
kill Gollum, though Harry may want to out of pity when he sees what 
Voldemort has become. 

I doubt Harry is a Horcrux; this has been argued against well and 
thoroughly in previous posts.

I don't think Harry will turn into Frodo Potter. He has too much 
resilience. If nothing else, his horrible childhood has taught him to 
bounce back. Perhaps that's why he's such a good dementor fighter.









More information about the HPforGrownups archive