DD Not Dead
Victoria Scott
little_scottie6 at hotmail.com
Sun Feb 19 03:23:32 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 148374
Gryffindor Chaser adds:
I've read other people's opinions on whether Snape said a nonverbal
spell while doing the AK curse on DD. So, collaborating what others
have said, and what I have read, I think that yes, Snape used the
AK curse, but since he didn't mean it, it still produced a green
flash, but only knocked DD off his feet, in the air and over the
ledge. In this way, it is possible, as when Harry used the
Unforgivable curse against Bellatrix in OotP, that the curse still
works, but not to its fullest extent.
Therefore, once DD was falling off the roof, he could have turned
into a phoenix, as he may have been an animagus, got to the ground,
picked up his wand, released Harry from the BB jinx and then
returned to his body. This answers all the questions about no
injuries after falling to the ground, still having his glasses
perfectly intact, and also the pheonix flying out of the white
swirls at his funeral!!
That is just my take on things.. so please write back and tell me
yours
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive