DDM!Snape clue

lagattalucianese katmac at katmac.cncdsl.com
Wed Feb 22 05:54:31 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 148557

> 
> Marcela:
> ***Wouldn't this be a perfect 'mirror' scene of what happened with
> > the Marauders' Prank on Snape?!   James saving Snape from being
> > bitten by werewolf!Lupin, and then Snape 'paying back' his life 
debt
> > to James by saving Harry from Fenrir's bite?
> > It makes me wonder if Snape still feels like he 'owes' something 
to
> > Harry, like Dumbledore suggested so in PS/SS...
> 
> Jen: If Snape did fulfill his life debt in that moment, that might 
be 
> meaningful for the future. Especially if Snape mainly turned back 
to 
> Dumbledore due to the life-debt. Then all bets would be off as to 
his 
> loyalty. Not saying I'm a fan of the idea, just that if JKR is 
taking 
> that route she'd have some more canon for it.
> 
> Jen R.
>
La Gatta Lucianese:

I thought Snape paid back his life-debt to James when he saved Harry 
from Quirrellmort in SS/PS. How many times does he have to bail Harry 
out to satisfy the debt?

If Snape did pay off the debt all the way back in SS/PS, and in HBP 
he's *still* bailing Harry out at least once and maybe twice, 
shouldn't that tell us something about where Snape stands vis-a-vis 
Voldemort and Harry?







More information about the HPforGrownups archive