Did Snape pay his life debt in PS/SS? WAS: Re: DDM!Snape clue

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 148592

Alla wrote:
> > Well, no I don't think he did fulfill his life-debt in PS/SS. 
<snip > > 
>Koinonia wrote:
> 
> Well, Harry states Snape saved his life. Does that not count for 
> anything?  :-)
> 
> GoF
> Ch 26
> 
<SNIP of the quote . Go UPTHREAD to read it>

Alla:

Sure, it may count for everything or it may not IMO. As I said we 
don't know how life debt works precisely, unless I am missing 
something. It is a possibility that a life debt is only fulfilled 
when the person who has a life debt considers it to be fulfilled, no?
If this is true, then Snape IMO does not act as the person whose 
obligations to Harry ended in PS/SS.

JMO of course.

Alla