[HPforGrownups] Re: Godricks Hollow location and Secret Keeping business

[Karen]

No: HPFGUIDX 148668


  ----- Original Message ----- 
  From: Steve 


  So, I guess my point is that no one is saying that the house or the
  graves with or will not be visible. We are looking at this new
  information and trying resolve our knowledge of the books with this
  information, and clear up inconsistencies. Speculation on the house or
  graves not being visible is just a case of thinking out loud while we
  try to understand and resolve the problems. 



  kchuplis: 

  Thanks all! I can't see at *all* why the secret would be still in effect once James and Lily are dead. To be honest, everything we've heard is "Voldemort was after James and Lily". DD knew about the prophecy but in one of those well meaning moves where we miss the obvious and instead, they probably *should* have made Harry the secret, not James and Lily or all three specifically. He must have been included somehow, but not specifically. Maybe I am being too simplistic again, but since the secret was to keep them safe, it seems their death would nullify it. But I'll continue to watch all the speculation. I wasn't clear on it because I miss things and it seemed like everything I read here was related to canon somehow so I was confoosed!! 

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]