Secret Keepers/JKR Poll Question - Confussion

[finwitch]

No: HPFGUIDX 148669

> 
> Christina:
> I really wish that the FAQ question had been a more general one about
> the FC, but we can't always get what we want.  I think that it's
> necessary to do a little fudging with the concept; otherwise, why
> doesn't somebody just put Harry under the FC - the secret being "Harry
> Potter exists" or "Harry Potter is in the UK" - then he could dance in
> the street without anybody knowing he was there, free to track down
> Voldemort's horcruxes and finally LV himself, all while being visible
> to a select few.

Finwitch:

Actually, that sort of spell would be quite dangerous... While wild
nature has the invisibility (back-ground-matchin colouring) as a
benefit, traffic for instance, requires that you be seen.

In addition, such spell would disable Harry from going shopping,
getting attention in hospital etc. impossible, and I doubt that a
piece of information that everyone (in wiz. world, anyway) *already
knows* can be put under Fidelius.

As for forgetting an adress etc. Why not? She hasn't visited all that
often, has she? She probably wouldn't even notice unless she needed
it. People do forget things all the time.

Finwitch