[HPforGrownups] Re: Of Souls and Death

[William Bernard]

No: HPFGUIDX 148827



        -Pamela:
    Destroying one would not destroy the other as
    they do not share a soul.  Harry, therefor, could not have been made 
    a horcrux by Voldemort the night he 'died'.

    Bill:
    I'm new here myself, but I just want to comment that I've come to the opposite conclusion: I believe that Harry will find that he is the "something from Gryffindor" horcrux. 
     
    Catherine adds:
     
    The real question is how exactly is a Horcrux made? 

  Bill again:
  That's exactly the question. We really don't know. My impression, supported by nothing, is that the spell to create the horcrux is done first and then the process is completed with the murder. There are too many unknowns at this stage to say.

  I based my conclusion on what I perceived was the most logical conclusion from statements made in the books.

  Bill


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]