Dumbledore's Death was planned

[Arlene]

No: HPFGUIDX 148893

> bboyminn:
> 
> I have one question that I always ask when people speculate that 
this
> was all planned by Dumbledore. How does Dumbledore enlist the
> cooperation of the Death Eaters? 

edited...

Would Dumbledore really fake his death by inviting Death Eaters into 
a castle filled with innocent students and teachers? 
 


Arlene here:
Thanks you guys for the imput

danitchlich, you made a good point about the wand being needed to 
retrieve the wand... However, Tonks made another good point that DD 
doesn't need a wand to save himself, and he's so powerful and great. 
Which I agree....Yet DD is dead. 

Which brings me to my original point that it was planned. 

I know Tonks say it was expected, but not planned.

I think it was planned. For the same reason Snape wasn't given the 
DA job any sooner than 14 years... it wasn't time yet.

As far bboyminn, I don't believe DD enlisted help from the DE (Just 
one Snape)nor did he "Invite" them into the school (I believe that 
was Draco). 

Did he know these things were going to happen.... maybe, would he 
have planned it on the same day he went after a Horcrux and drank 
poison and was weakend no I don't think that was planned. 

What I do think was planned, was that IF the DE's ever surrounded 
him and Snape had to PROVE himself in front of DD, and someone had 
to die..... it would have to be DD (for a number of reasons).

It HAD to be Snape. which is why DD was asking only for him.

Arlene.