compairing Scrimgeour to Fudge.

corey_over coverton at netscape.com
Sun Jan 1 14:27:57 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 145693

Hi every one. Corey again.
I'm going to try to compair Rufus Scrimgeour to Fudge.

Why I think Scrimgeour is better than Fudge was.
1. He fought dark wisards for most of his life. 
2. Scrimgeour is more decisive than Fudge as Dumbledore said in HBP chapter 3.
3. Scrimgeour had security at Hogwarts where as Fudge I don't think 
would have done very well at this.
4. Scrimgeour has made his mistakes ie puting Stan Stunpike in Azkaban. 
That was admitedly stupid. but I think he's is a better minister than 
was Fudge. Fudge was after all sacked. Not saying that Scrimgeour won't be but if Scrimgeour is sacked who will take over next? Just some stuff to think about. Please lets pray to the bookgods that if Scrimgeour is sacked that Umbridge won't be Minister. That would be a nightmare. Just some thoughts. 

Your fellow list member Corey leaving for now.










More information about the HPforGrownups archive