Real child abuse/ Snape again

[horridporrid03]

No: HPFGUIDX 145734

> >>Alla:
> <snip>
> Torturing Draco - sorry, I will sign it off to rough justice again 
> and I think that Real!Moody would not have been above doing it.    
> IMO of course. 
> <snip>

Betsy Hp:
Now how on earth am I supposed to take your opinions about child 
abuse seriously when you say torturing a child is okay?  That *is* 
what you're saying, yes?  Dropping a transfigured Draco onto a stone 
floor from such a hight he actually bounces is fine and dandy.  
Catching Harry in the middle of a wrong doing and calling him on it 
is abuse.  I'm sorry, but your logic completely escapes me.

I'd also like to think that the real Moody would beg to differ with 
your view that he'd eagerly torture a child.  After all, Sirius told 
us he tried not to use the Unforgivables to fight the Death Eaters.  
Throwing an Imperius at Bellatrix seems much more forgivable, to my 
mind, than using a form of physical and emotional torture on a 
schoolboy.  I'd like to think the real Moody would agree.  

Now, Umbridge, on the other hand, I think she'd agree with you 
completely.  She's all about "rough justice".

Betsy Hp