C!M Imperius/no more dueling

[kchuplis]

No: HPFGUIDX 145741

> Pippin:
> We can't be sure that Harry actually fought off the imperius 
> that Fake!Moody put on him. It'd be easy enough for Fake!Moody 
> to lift the spell non-verbally and lie about it, tricking Harry
> into thinking that he'd fought it successfully. Then, when Harry 
> faced Voldemort's Imperius, he "knew", just like with the 
> patronus spell, that he'd done it before. 


But he really HAD done it before in the case of the patronus, not 
just THOUGHT he had done it before.  I don't see the two situations 
as being mutual. 

kchuplis