Merope's life and real abusers and Hermione and Fleur.

zgirnius zgirnius at yahoo.com
Wed Jan 4 21:25:37 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 145906

"Corey Overton" <coverton at n...> wrote:
> 1. Hermione doesn't respect Fleur in my eyes. Want cannon to validate
> this? Here it is. I believe in Ron's room Harry, Ginny, and Hermione 
are
> all talking. Harry and Ron are talking about Fleur. don't have the 
tape
> in front of me so I'm going on memory.Hermione says "not you as 
well",referring to Harry. This to me is a lack of respect of Fleur. 

zgirnius:
First, sorry, I do not recall either whether it was Ginny or Hermione. 
But I think we really can't conclude from this interaction much about 
how Hermione values Fleur as a person or as a witch. What I think this 
scene is about is Ron. Hermione (quite naturally) is irked that Ron is 
so obviously and strongly affected by Fleur's physical attractions. 
This is the same Ron who claimed only to notice that Hermione was a 
girl when he so desperately needed a date in GoF for the Yule Ball.

(I do agree with you about Merope-hence the snipping...)







More information about the HPforGrownups archive