TBAY: Re: DD and Godric's Hollow (Long) Draught of Living Death, DD&Snape in HBP

[esmith222002]

No: HPFGUIDX 145915

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, fuzzlebub85 at a... wrote:
>
> Kaylee Tonks-Lupin here answering her Captain's call! 
>  
>  
> Kaylee Tonks-Lupin is strolling along the beach of Theory Bay, when 
she  sees 
> Brothergib standing on the shore. He looks rather lost. She walks 
up to  
> Brothergib and politely asks, "May I help you?" He nods. 
>  

I feel like I'm intruding!! And despite a thorough search, I cannot 
find the suitable ingredients to make a margarita - so I am 
(unfortunately) completely sober!

However, if your theory is correct, DD was desperately trying to find 
Sirius, so he could apply this ointment. Therefore, at the time of 
Voldemort's defeat he didn't know Harry was at Godric's Hollow. So 
who told DD that Harry had defeated Voldemort? You seem to suggest 
that Snape was at Hogwarts ready to apply the ointment. Someone must 
have told DD?

Brothergib thanks Kaylee, waves to the others on the boat and 
continues on up the beach, scratching his head.


> 
> Brothergib:<snip>
> 
> 
> > So where did DD disappear to from the time when Voldemort was  
> > defeated, to the moment he finally arrived at Privet Drive? 
>  
> Kaylee smiles. "Why, I believe I hear my Captain calling!" Indeed,  
Susan's 
> voice can be clearly heard: 
> 
> 
> SSSusan:
> Ahem.  Jen, Potioncat, Kaylee, other crewmates on the  DRIBBLE 
> SHADOWS -- 'tis tooting our own horn time! ;-)  
>  
> Kaylee grins. "Come on, Brothergib! I'll show you the best idea 
I've seen  
> yet!" She grabs Brothergib's hand and pulls him toward the DRIBBLE 
SHADOWS. When 
>  they reach the deck, she lets Captain SSSusan explain further:
>  
> SSSusan:
> IOW, time to 
> resurrect our theory of what happened in the "missing 24  hours."   
> 
> Some of us believe that DD may have used that time  to "shore up" 
the 
> protections on Harry, not believing Voldy to be fully gone  for all 
> time.  It's my contention that DD, Hagrid & Snape worked  together 
to 
> apply a protective potion/ointment containing dragon blood onto  
baby 
> Harry during those 24 hours.  
> 
> If you're interested, here's  where it starts, and there are 
several 
> follow-ups &  responses:
> http://groups.yahoo.com/group/HPforGrownups/message/128717
> 
> 
> Brothergib:
> >  Sirius (who is not at Hogwarts) also receives this information 
and 
> >  rushes off to Godric's Hollow. 
> 
> SSSusan:
> I think that Sirius realized  something was wrong because he was 
> supposed to have met up with PP, who did  not show.  In my version 
of 
> things, Sirius dashed off to GH to see if  everything was alright 
and 
> just *happened* upon the awful scene, as opposed  to having been 
> officially informed about it by DD or someone  else.
>  
> Kaylee nods. "It makes a lot of sense," she says breathlessly, 
giving her  
> Captain an almost worshipful look. "Rule number one: The captain is 
always  
> right! Oh wait, that's Captain Amber's rule...well, it can be 
Captain Susan's  
> too," she decides. "Anyway, Brothergib, Dragon's Resistance In 
Blood Bestows  
> Life-saving Effects: Snape, 
> Hagrid And Dumbledore's Ointment Was Supplement  is what it stands 
for. I 
> know some people probably don't believe Snape would  make the 
ointment 
> after...after HBP," she admits, lowering her eyes for a moment  of 
silence. "But I 
> believe there's still the issue of why Snape was trusted by  
Dumbledore. That all 
> fits in here. And..." Kaylee lowered her voice. "Here. I'll  need 
the relevant 
> canon in HBP...bad me, I know, not having the book on hand..."  
Kaylee 
> blushed. "Brothergib, Captain Sue, perhaps Jen, 
Potioncat...someone?" she  begs. "I 
> know that Draughts of the Living Death ought to be important.  I'm 
sure Snape 
> brewed one for Dumbledore. He had to  have." She has a wild, almost 
hysterical 
> look in her eyes. "Snape can't be  evil! He just can't! Dumbledore 
isn't 
> dead!" 
> She throws herself into the sand and beats her fists on  her beach 
towel, 
> howling in pain, anger, and denial. Kaylee knew she'd  gotten way 
off topic, but 
> it had to be said.
>  
> ~Kaylee Tonks-Lupin, apologizing profusely to the Elves 
> 
> 
> Siriusly Snapey Susan, cap'n of the not especially sea-worthy but  
> still floatin', I think, DRIBBLE SHADOWS 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>