[HPforGrownups] Re: First Potions lesson

[P J]

No: HPFGUIDX 145929



Orna:
I don't think so  not on earth. I just said that Snape, who
probably hadn't any information of how Harry spent his first 11
years, could assume that he was raised in a family glorifying his
parents, and allowing him to read books.

PJ:
Ok, but if Snape is so close to Dumbledore WHY doesn't he know this stuff 
about Harry?  It's no secret since, when asked by McG. Dumbledore tells her 
clearly where Harry will live and, most importantly, why.  he didn't fudge 
or hesitate with her at all!

For Snape to think Harry has lived a life of ease and glory for the past 11 
years suggests that he's seriously out of the loop with Dumbledore.  At 
least it does to me and if that's true, the rest of the books take on a 
whole new light with Snape, don't they?

PJ