Subject: Re: Potion in the Cave

[h2so3f]

No: HPFGUIDX 146009

Nicky Joe wrote:
" I'm actually wondering if Regulus tried to destroy the Horcrux and 
ended up frying himself in the process. They say he was "killed by 
LV" but never mentions how. The other Blacks and DEs would have 
assumed LV killed him because he was already in disfavor. And 
depending on the timing (interesting how timing is everything when 
it comes to the final book) R.A.B. could have been taking the locket 
about the time LV was preoccupied with the Potters, which is why LV 
never discovered the Horcrux was missing."


CH3ed:
Well if Regulus was killed by LV or his DEs then there would have 
been a dark mark hovering over his body, ay? That is how DD knew the 
DEs hadn't ambushed Slug when DD and Harry found his house in a 
busted state.

CH3ed confesses to have missed Carol's original post containing the 
Bella theory entirely and would really appreciate a reminder of the 
thread number so he can look it up. :O) Thanks!!