[HPforGrownups] Son of Snape

Bee Chase luckdragon64 at yahoo.ca
Sun Jan 8 22:43:06 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 146118



skatinglibrarian <linda_hay at fc.brattleboro.k12.vt.us> wrote:    Second, to the question "was Snape ever loved" JKR says on her 
web site "yes". And I think I may have noticed something. When 
Harry gets into Snape's memory, he sees a hooked nose man 
yelling at a woman who is cowering, as a dark haired little boy 
looks on. What if the hook nosed man is Snape, the cowering 
woman his wife and the little boy his son?

Now that we know about Unbreakable vows ... is there the 
possibility that there was one between Dumbledore and Snape? 
Dumbeldore will keep Snape's son hidden if Snape will work for 
the order?

Luckdragon:
  I think if the hook nosed man in Snapes memory was Snape Harry would have recognised him, so I do believe Snape was the child in this memory.
  As for the unbreakable vow, yes; I do believe the one thing that would make DD trust Snape is if he had made an UV with him. This is why I cannot accept the ESE Snape theory. If DD really is dead, I believe Snape had to do the deed and his "Severus please" was akin to Petunia's "remember my last".


		
---------------------------------
Find your next car at Yahoo! Canada Autos

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]





More information about the HPforGrownups archive