Is Tonks clumsy or not?

ginny343 ginny343 at yahoo.com
Mon Jan 9 00:29:34 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 146120

I can accept Tonks' change of patronus, her moodiness, her unability 
to change her appearance as being upset about her situation with 
Lupin.  But what happened with her being clumsy?  I felt that was a 
major part of her character development in OoP and I don't remember 
seeing any clumsiness in HBP.  I can't imagine this as an oversight, 
surely JKR's editors would have noticed.  It must be intentional.  Any 
ideas on what is going on with this?  Or did I just miss the clumsy 
parts?

:) Ginny343







More information about the HPforGrownups archive