Did Snape see Peter on the Map or not? WAS: Re: Essays about Snape on Lexicon

[h2so3f]

No: HPFGUIDX 146127

Alla asked: <snip>
"Do we even know from anybody else that Shack is indeed off the Map? 
I just don't remember, but it could be so of course."


CH3ed:
I don't have PoA with me, but I remember when the twins gave Harry 
the Marauder's Map all three of them examined it and Harry noticed 
that several tunnels run off the map in the direction of Hogsmeade 
(but Hogmeade itself is off the Map). 

It seems they also knew where the other tunnels go to, except for 
the one with the Whomping Willow guarding it, so I'd deduce that the 
Shrieking Shack isn't on the Map (the twins either have gotten 
caugth by Filch in or around the tunnels that they said that Filch 
knew about, or they've seen Filch use them. And another tunnel also 
leads to an unknown location in Hogsmeade but is now inaccessible 
due to a cave in during Harry's 2nd year).

CH3ed  :O)